UNITED
NATIONS - As is well known, diplomats are not paid
to tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing
but the truth. Iraq's ambassadors are not the only
ones sent abroad to lie for their country. Also,
diplomacy ought not to be equated necessarily with
civility. Diplomats can be rude individually. Collectively,
they may be even ruder.
Case in point: the
exodus from the UN
General Assembly hall
minutes after President
George W. Bush concluded
his important address
on what Iraq and the
world body needed to
do to avert a second
round of the Gulf war.
Of course, no delegate
could compete with
Bush in a contest for
public attention, but
aren't we always being
reminded that in the
UN all states are equal?
The
annual debate in
the General Assembly,
for which presidents
and prime ministers
cross oceans, is a
rare opportunity for
those less equal than
others to air their
achievements and grouse
their grievances. If
the UN is really an
organization of "We,
the peoples," as
it professes, every
speaker is entitled
to a substantial and
respectful audience
and ought not to be
humiliated by the sight
of row after row of
empty seats.
The situation is often
so bad that television
camera operators keep
their lenses focused
on a speaker, lest
a shot of all those
unoccupied benches
reach the audience
back in the home country,
damaging the VIP's
credibility and a nation's
reputation.
Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg,
the UN's host in a
way, addressed the
General Assembly a
day after Bush's appearance.
Perhaps delegates had
not checked the speakers
list and were unaware
that he would be speaking.
Whatever the reason,
there was considerable
absenteeism. After
what New York has gone
through, with fears
still that there may
be more bad things
to come, a large audience
would have been a welcome
display of interest,
sympathy and support
for the UN's home city.
It's highly unusual
for a mayor to be invited
to speak in the General
Assembly, and Bloomberg
was duly conscious
of the honor, arranging
for his mother, sister
and daughter to be
in the audience, along
with several members
of his administration
as well as personal
friends. They may have
been surprised that
the city's chief magistrate
did not draw a bigger
crowd. (It is to be
hoped that Gillian
Sorensen or Shashi
Tharoor or another
senior member of the
UN secretariat explained
that delegates surely
intended no offense.)
Rudolph
W. Giuliani received
a heartier
welcome last year,
but that was soon after
the tragedy of Sept.
11. Some have sought
to explain the lukewarm
response to Bloomberg
as a reaction to the
latest round of hostilities
in an ongoing war between
the city and the diplomatic
and consular corps
over (what else?) parking
violations and unpaid
fines. When the mayor
alluded to this, there
was some polite tittering
in the audience, but
many delegates still
believe that the city
government is insufficiently
appreciative of the
UN"s contribution
to the New York region's
economy or of the honor
of hosting the organization.
How else could New
York uphold its claim
to be capital of the
world?
Secretary
General Kofi Annan
has made
it a policy to promote
cordial relations with
Governor George Pataki
and Mayor Bloomberg
as well as with other
leaders in state and
city politics and in
other sectors, public
and private. "From
my vantagepoint, New
York City's relationship
with the UN has never
been better than it
is today," the
mayor said, in confirmation
of the success of Annan's
outreach.
Of course, not every
citizen agrees with
that. New Yorkers'
tempers are frayed
whenever the UN brings
on a big show, streets
are blocked, bus routes
are changed and police
escorts clear traffic
lanes for visiting
VIPs.
The value of the UN
presence is estimated
at between $3 billion
and $4 billion a year,
not to mention the
thousands of jobs associated
with it. It probably
would not be a good
idea for Annan to launch
a publicity campaign
that made these economic
benefits a central
point; the organization
remains controversial
enough for Bloomberg
not to be tempted to
beat the UN drum.
The week of Sept.
23, hopefully most
of the visitors will
have departed and the
city have settled down
again. Until the next
time.
|