Skip to content

Politics

Does the Bird's Point floodway case reveal a problem with the Clean Water Act?

by Michael Clark 26 May 2011
Does the Bird's Point floodway case reveal a problem with the Clean Water Act?

On May 2, the Army Corps of Engineers blew up Birds Point levee, in Missouri, to redirect the surging Mississippi River, virtually saving the upstream town of Cairo, Illinois and likely averting significant additional downstream flood damage. Like a relief valve, the broken levee allowed floodwaters to discharge into the Birds Point-New Madrid Floodway, an area comprised of 130,000 acres of largely agricultural land and 200 homes. The right to flood the low lying area was purchased as easements by the federal government, after the passage of the law, the Flood Control Act of 1928, that authorized the floodways. The Corps decides when to 'operate' the floodway, one of four along the river.

The floodways were a new concept. Prior to the massive floods of 1927, managing the Mississippi was limited to building higher and higher levees. The floodways essentially introduced a means to relieve flooding, but they were controversial. The Birds Point Floodway system took 14 years to complete due to myriad lawsuits brought by residents claiming its construction amounted to a taking of their property. In short, they wanted compensation, which many of them received, though not all. To this day, there is property within the floodway for which the federal government has not secured flowage rights.

Though incomplete, the floodway was last 'operated' in 1937 but only after the National Guard was deployed to drive off armed residents preventing Corps personnel from blowing up the levee. Over the years, the operations plan for the floodway has changed several times. The destruction of the levee on May 2 was predicated on the most recent operations plan, written in 1986.

Historically, opposition to the floodway was largely centered on property rights issues. However, the recent injunction application filed by the State of Missouri Attorney General, Chris Koster, to prevent the destruction of the Birds Point levee asserted that operating the floodway constitutes a violation of Missouri's Clean Water Act. Mr Koster argues that the release of floodwaters may result in the contamination of state waters, a direct of violation of Missouri's Clean Water Act, and points to the section in the federal Clean Water Act that supports his thesis that the Corps is subject to state water quality laws.

The court, in its opinion, states that the federal Clean Water Act includes an exception that protects the Army and its mandate to maintain navigation. This, the court maintains, is a direct reference to the Corps' mission of flood control and navigability. Since the floodway serves the purpose of maintaining navigability, an assertion that is based on flimsy testimony recounted in the opinion, the Corps is exempt from Missouri's Clean Water Act, the court concluded.

However, the court went on: ''If indeed the plaintiffs are correct [that the Corps is subject to state clean water act laws], then [the Clean Water Act] eviscerates the core functions of the Corps under the Flood Control Act.'' It would appear that, based narrowly on the law, the plaintiffs are incorrect, but it raises a critical legal flaw, in that local water quality regulations may be violated for purposes of flood control and navigation. Though flood control and navigability are critical and often save lives and mitigate economic impacts, they should not be achieved at the expense of local water quality. Also, there appears to be no legal recourse for states if water contamination or violations occur as a result of floodway operation.

The case speaks to the broader issue of a fractured federal water resources management system. USGS measures water quantity, EPA regulates water quality, NOAA predicts flood events, the Corps oversees flood control, etc. There is a need to integrate these services, in which flooding and water quality concerns are given voice. A good first step was taken recently when USGS, NOAA, and the Corps announced a new partnership to foster collaborative water resources management across the agencies. Much remains to be done, but it seems a legal loophole that sacrifices water quality for navigation needs mending.


Trending Eco-Friendly Clothing

Love My Planet Women's Relaxed Fit Hoodie
Earth
Quick Add
Close
Notify me
Notify me
Love My Planet Women's Relaxed Fit Hoodie
Love My Planet women's eco-friendly relaxed fit hoodieSize Guide Centimeters 8 10 12 14 16 18 Bust 84 88 92 97 103 108 Waist 66 70 75 80 85 91 Hips 91 95 99 104 109 116 Bust: Measure around the fullest part of...
£38.00
£38.00
Close
Notify me
Notify me
Penguins Hate Push-Ups Men's Pullover Hoodie
Earth
Quick Add
Close
Notify me
Notify me
Penguins Hate Push-Ups Men's Pullover Hoodie
Penguins Hate Push-Ups men's eco-friendly pullover HoodieSize Guide Centimeters XS S M L XL XXL Height 171 175 179 183 189 195 Chest 86 93 99 104 116 129 Waist 71 76 81 89 99 112 Chest: Measure all round your chest just below...
£38.00
£38.00
Close
Notify me
Notify me
Lightning Bolt Kids Long Sleeve T-Shirt
Earth
Quick Add
Close
Notify me
Notify me
Notify me
Lightning Bolt Kids Long Sleeve T-Shirt
Lightning Bolt kids eco-friendly long sleeve t-shirtSize Guide Centimeters 3-4yrs 5-6yrs 7-8yrs 9-10yrs 11-12yrs Height 98 112 125 136 147 Chest 60 66 70 75 84 Chest: Measure all around your chest just below your armpits. Height: Your natural height If you fall between...
£18.00
£18.00
Close
Notify me
Notify me
Notify me
Union Jack Tote Bag
Earth
Quick Add
Close
Notify me
Notify me
Union Jack Tote Bag
Union Jack eco-friendly colour tote bagProduct Specification Organic Cotton Tote Bag. Twill Weave (170gsm). 37 x 42 cm (7cm gusset.) Made in India / Designed on the Isle of Wight. Wash Cool, Hang Dry.
£16.00
£16.00
Close
Notify me
Notify me
Prev Post
Next Post

Eco-Friendly Shop

Women's Clothing

Eco-Friendly Clothing for Women Our online shop offers a wide range of sustainable women’s clothing products, including t-shirts, hoodies, vests, sweaters, shorts, and...
Shop Now

Men's Clothing

Eco-Friendly Clothing for Men Our online shop offers a wide range of sustainable men’s clothing products, including t-shirts, hoodies, vests, sweaters, shorts, and...
Shop Now

Kids Clothing

Eco-Friendly Clothes for Kids Our online shop offers a wide range of sustainable kids clothing products, including t-shirts, hoodies and jumpers. Our garments...
Shop Now
Someone recently bought a
[time] ago, from [location]

Thanks for subscribing!

This email has been registered!

Shop the look

Choose Options

Earth Times
Sign up for exclusive updates, new arrivals & insider only discounts

Recently Viewed

Edit Option
Back In Stock Notification
this is just a warning
Login
Shopping Cart
0 items

Before you leave...

Take 20% off your first order

20% off

Enter the code below at checkout to get 20% off your first order

CODESALE20

Continue Shopping