I
took a lot of work, a lot of cooperation and
the full involvement of various aspects
of society. But if all goes as planned, Cambodia
may soon become the upheld model for "least
developed" countries.
From
the look of the thick 104-page research report that
Cambodian officials have put together to present at
the WTO conference-the nation is determined to rise
from poverty. And the only way out, they are convinced,
is through trade capacity building and following an
integrated framework. In fact, it was chosen as one
of three pilot projects by the Organization For Economic
Co-operation and Development (OECD), a Paris based
organization that helps governments with the economic,
social and governance challenges of a globalized economy.
Cambodia which
was in the process of strengthening their trade
policy was the perfect pilot project
candidate. "We have been working on opening
our market access for eight years," said Sok
Siphana, the Secretary of State from the Ministry
of Commerce.
"We signed many bilateral agreement and we
are the only LDC country out of the 49 countries
that have exceeded the $1billion dollar export
mark." But Cambodia would soon discover that
their problem is one of capacity or "our non-ability
to produce the goods and the services to sell to
export," said Siphana. They came across many
obstacles, or as Siphana called them, bottlenecks.
"There are many issues including trade facilitations,
standards, the infrastructure, and the capacity
to understand the multi-lateral trade agreements," he
said. "We felt that unless we can remove those
bottlenecks, we will not be able to draw maximum
benefit from the multilateral trading system and
that's why we began this reform."
Their efforts impressed the OECD who in April
included them with Madagascar and Mauritania as
pilot projects. The OECD provided them with technical
assistance when the country came across bottlenecks.
It was a boost the country needed and Cambodian
officials set to work developing a new national
strategy.
"We analyzed our entire structure, we analyzed
our macro-economic situation, we looked at the
issues facing our negotiations to enter the WTO," said
Siphana. "In each sector we looked at what
is the potential. Not only in our country. But
what are the constraints and rules in the importing
country, in the EU, in US, in Japan and in other
countries which prevent us from maximizing our
potential."
The effort was tremendous. All the governmental
ministries cooperated and a new national strategy
mapped out. Ministerial portfolios were shifted
when necessary. Stakeholders, the private sector,
business associations, the academia and civil society
were put into action.
"Everybody was involved in this process," said
Siphana. "This is national anxiety. It's not
just the worry of the Ministry of Commerce coming
to the meeting of the WTO. This is about the survival
of the country."
Whoever was not
involved became involved. A think tank of 100
government, business, and civil society
formed a coherent work team to discuss every issue. "We
looked at the rice which is our main food, we looked
at agriculture, fish industry, garments, tourism,
labor service, everything and handicraft," he
said. "We felt those are the key sectors that
allow revenue for our economy."
Seven months later, an impressive 104 pages of
detailed report outlining Cambodia's sectors and
trade strategy was published. On November 19 and
20, a national workshop will be held in the country
to bring about an action plan based on the report.
The study was based
on the OECD's guidelines on strengthening trade
capacity building for development.
The importance of the capacity building is reflected
in the Draft Ministerial declaration which is being
considered during this conference. "We underscore
the urgent necessity for the effective coordinated
delivery of technical assistance with bilateral
donors, in the OECD Development Assistance Committee
and relevant international and regional intergovernmental
institutions, within a coherent policy framework
and timetable," states article 33 of the Draft.
In his opening
speech on Friday, Mike Moore, the WTO's director-general
stressed that "capacity
problems, not trade barriers, are the major obstacles
to growth in developing countries," he said. "...
The new Integrated Framework will be a model of
inter-agency cooperation and coherence, enabling
us to multiply our modest resources by working
with other agencies to assist developing countries
on the ground." The main instrument in strengthening
trade capacity is based on the Integrated Framework
for Trade-Related Technical Assistance to LDCs
- or better known as "IF"
IF core agencies (WTO, UNCTAD, ITC, World Bank,
IMF and UNDP), and representative from bilateral
agencies were brought together to help prepare
the OECD's guidelines - currently adopted by the
three pilot countries.
"It's a way in which we can effectively help
developing countries get more capacity to trade," said
Richard Carey the deputy director of the Development
Co-operation Directorate of the OECD. "The
Development Assistance Committee (in OECD) produced
these guidelines so that bilateral donors be an
effective partner for developing countries."
The idea is to
get LDCs to identify the problems they must deal
with and get them to adopt a "trade
policy which is integrated with the overall development
strategy so that they see trade as part of the
economic strategy as a whole," continued Carey. "So
it's no longer a box of its own but a part the
overall economic development process."
This includes injecting the newly adopted trade
policies into a country's poverty reduction strategy,
developing the LDC economy and building institutions.
"It's important to start a process in the
developing country which will continue on and be
sustainable," said Carey, "because these
problems have to be addressed over a period of
years."
The National Development Strategy model-which
LDCs are encouraged to adopt-outlined in the guidelines
depends on the coordination of government ministries
and agencies, the private sector and business associations,
the civil society, academia and research institutions.
It is up to them to form a coherent working group,
identify the country's problems and come out with
a national strategy. Hovering nearby is the OECD-who
provides advice, technical assistance and ways
to overcome hurdles.
It is the model
which Cambodia has adopted to revamp its national
strategy. Cambodia's capacity
building strategy has managed to attract the World
Bank. "This process we're engaged in Cambodia
is really the first step along the way to try to
identify what the priorities are," said Bernard
Hoekman, the World Bank's Policy and Research Manager
of International Trade in the Development Research
Group and Economic Policy Unit. "The idea
is that once you identify the priorities - how
do you deal with them? And this is quite frequently
going to be sector specific."
In its newly released
just released its report "Global
Economic Prospects and the Developing Countries
2002" The World Bank reviews the global economic
environment and its implications for the developing
countries over the next decade.
"It looks at the market access agenda asking
how you would strengthen the global trade architecture
for developments," said Hoekman. "The
key focus is trying to figure out how the trade
fits into the bigger development process and how
to use trade as poverty-reducing growth."
The report recognizes that developing countries
have a huge amount to gain from getting rid of
the many barriers that remain, especially in agriculture,
textile and clothing.
"It will increase their incomes, reduce poverty,
raise an additional 300 million people out of poverty
- which is really important in Sub-Sahara and Africa," he
said, "because our projections show that absent
initiatives like trade liberalization means that
the number of poor in absolute terms are going
to grow."
To approve the funding for Cambodia, the World
Bank is doing its own share of studies into the
country.
"We're looking at what the countries produce,
where their comparative advantages are and what
needs to be done by other countries in order to
enhance their access to the markets," he said. "A
good chunk of these report and a good part of the
analysis done by the Bank focuses on where the
market access barriers are and what do they imply
in terms of the impact on the poor in these countries."
Obtaining the needed funds from the World Bank
or bilateral donors seems hopeful for Cambodia.
Siphana projects a growth of eight or nine percent
in 10 years time if their national strategy is
implemented as planned and a transformed country
in 20 years time.
"Cambodia," concluded Hoekman, "is
a key test."
|