The
Doha Meeting of the World Trade Organization
has a specific mandate-trade. This is not
a meeting for hand-holding or ensuring that
all parties are one hundred percent satisfied;
countries will have to compromise and work
long into the night while trying to come up
with the best possible solutions to problems
of world trade.
"There's
no question of happiness or unhappiness in trade matters," said
Nripendra Misra, Special Secretary in the Indian Department
of Commerce. "It's a matter of dollars and cents."
Bringing 143 countries, plus numerous observer
countries and organizations together to a consensus
decision is not easy. Mike Moore, WTO Director
General, has consistently stressed the importance
of countries working together and the fact that
the WTO is a consensus body. Member countries,
however, have very different issues on their agendas
and now the challenge for delegates is to find
ways to compromise on issues without compromising
on their needs. Even with the diversity of agendas
and the strong stance countries are taking toward
these talks, the fact remains that the WTO has
a role, and it is essential for countries that
want to increase world trade.
"We [in the WTO] have more countries now
than ever, and even more want to join," said
Andre Lemay, Deputy Director for Trade in the Canadian
Department of International Trade. "China's
drive to join the WTO is proof that even a former
centrally controlled economy like China's has something
to contribute, as well as something to gain from
being a member."
Some members, predominantly
developing countries, strongly criticized the
draft Ministerial Declaration
during the General Council meeting in Geneva, calling
the pre-meeting process undemocratic. "I am
constrained to point out that the draft Ministerial
Declaration is neither fair nor just to the view
points of many developing countries including my
own on certain key issues," Murasoli Maran,
Minister of Commerce and Industry for India said
in his statement to the plenary Saturday. "It
appears that the whole process was a mere formality
and we [developing countries] are being coerced
against our will."
Developing countries
are looking for more work to be done on implementation
before new issues,
the so-called "Singapore issues," are
discussed. Developed countries, want to see simultaneous
work to be done on competition policies and investment,
two issues that developing countries are holding
back on. "Lack of transparency in investment
and competition rules still holds back international
trade," said Baroness Symons of Vernham Dean,
United Kingdom Minister of Trade and Investment.
For many developing countries the implementation
issues are the main reason for trade still being
hampered.
"Unless you talk about implementation issues
together with new issues as a package we won't
feel that this is actually a better future for
us," said Hatanto Reksodipoetro, Director
General of the International Cooperation for Industry
and Trade. "It would rather be an additional
burden on us."
Despite these differences
developing countries present at Doha seem to
be gritting their teeth
and looking for ways to find compromise. "India
is very constructively engaged in the whole process," said
Misra. "There have been meetings of all countries,
which is a very constructive process in the WTO.
Meetings are not being confined to coalition of
interest groups."
Numerous meetings are already taking place behind
the scenes and delegations are setting up briefing
after briefing to get their points across to the
media and other representatives-that they mean
business. Even as they criticize the pre-ministerial
process of being undemocratic and not transparent,
delegates stress that the forum serves as a positive
and open means of communications with other countries,
even if only to disagree.
"It's always interesting to see how the point
of view differs from country to country and from
interest to interest," said Lemay. "We'll
seeing very diverse points of view, diverse perspectives,
diverse approaches." One point of convergence
for most members is that this round must help developing
countries. "Generally speaking this round
has to be a developing round-it has to assist developing
countries in developing their economy," said
Reksodipoetro. Pakistan's minister for commerce,
industries and production, Abdul Razak Dawood,
echoed these sentiments in the opening statement. "Our
ambitions are not limited to merely launching a
'new Round.' "Development round" will
be an oxymoron, if not a deception, so long as
it does not give priority to the development objectives
of the developing countries."
Globalization has become a four-letter word to
some people-a fact that would be highlighted if
protesters were allowed at the conference-but it
is central to the working of current society. And
the WTO, as an organization that promotes global
trades and links is here to stay.
|