After an eight year
decline under Mayor Rudolph Giuliani's
stern and unflexing thumb, street crime
is now more prevalent throughout New York
City.
But
nobody seems to be complaining.
"I haven't noticed any rise," noted
Ivo Perez, 66, who holds a government position
and works in the Federal Plaza in downtown Manhattan. "The
only things on the street are peddlers selling
pictures of the World Trade Center."
"Definitely," agreed Sandra Pizarro,
24, a Berkeley College student from Manhattan,
when asked if she has noticed a rise in peddling. "American
flags and Fallen Heroes tee shirts‹that's
all they sell now."
But in reference
to more serious crimes like the sale of narcotics,
Pizarro seemed almost taken
aback. "I would think the opposite," she
said. "At least in Midtown, you can't take
five steps without running into a National Guard."
Reports from the
New York Police Department indicate that while
the seven index crimes, which include
homicide, rape and various degrees of larceny,
were declining during the two months following
the World Trade Center attacks as steadily as they
have for almost a decade, street crimes like drug-dealing
and prostitution, as well as "quality of life" offenses
like peddling and panhandling have, in fact, drastically
risen since September 11. Only recently, over the
past three weeks, have shootings and slayings increased‹slightly.
A detective from the Manhattan South Narcotics
District confirmed that the sale of heroin, crack
and marijuana rose sharply during the month of
October, relative to the solid decline in August
and September. Similarly, a detective from the
Manhattan North Initiative's narcotics division
covering Midtown between 14th and 57th Street also
noted that the sale of crack and heroin escalated
throughout October.
Both attributed
the sudden upsurge to a lack of available officers
on the street after the World
Trade Center attacks. "The perpetrators noticed
we were gone for awhile and must have figured we'd
be gone longer," the Manhattan North detective
said. Officers agreed to speak with the Earth Times
on condition of anonymity.
A sergeant from
the Investigations Unit of the New York City
Traffic Control Division, whose team
was assigned to Ground Zero‹moments after
the first plane hit. Like many others, his team
was stationed at the site of the tragedy for over
a month, he said, and the pressing need for personnel
drew attention away from street crime. "I
began to notice all my vice guys and narcotics
detectives down at the site those first few weeks," he
said. "We were getting between 60 and 65 a
day."
Most of the narcotics
detectives told the sergeant they noticed a significant
rise in drug-related
crimes. "When they go back to their posts,
there are a lot more [perpetrators] around," he
said. "They're not stupid‹they know
we can't come down as hard as we were before and
they're taking more chances."
He added, "I'm
sure prostitution and gambling will go up too.
There just aren't enough officers
to fully cover both places at once."
While officers have certainly observed an increase
in crime, a look at the arrest data would seem
to contradict the current trend. Narcotics arrests
were significantly higher at this time last year:
there were 1,939 narcotics related arrests made
during the third week of November in 2000 as opposed
to the 1,154 made over the same period this year.
Furthermore, there were only 56,209 overall narcotics
arrests this year to date, as compared with last
year's 73,437.
This does not mean, however, that crime itself
has been on the decline. Law enforcement officers
have simply been making fewer arrests for those
same crimes; the crisis has fewer cops available
to cover narcotics posts since September 11.
Ironically, many
people believe to have observed an increase in
law enforcement since the attacks.
Of the 30 New Yorkers informally interviewed, a
staggering 27 feel police presence is as high as
ever, if not higher. "It seemed like there
were more cops around after [the attack]," observed
Stephanie Leonhardt, 26. "On Halloween there
were more officers on the street than people."
Leonhardt said
that while she has definitely noticed drug dealers,
they seemed to frequent the same
places they had been before the attack. "Oh,
I get offers in Washington Square Park all the
time," she admitted. "But it was always
like that. A guy I knew used to come here to get
heroin, and that was months before the attack.
Even with cops around, people have always known
this was the place for that stuff."
Kobena Bentil,
a quality engineer for New York City subways,
said that even the prostitutes who
often loitered terminals at night were absent of
late. "I have access to all the entrances
and hideouts and I haven't noticed any such rise," Bentil
said. "If anything, there has been increased
security and training."
Manhattan Transport
Authority (MTA) contractor Curtis Ewing felt
a similar police presence‹just
not a conspicuous one. "There are less uniformed
cops around, but believe me, the others are still
patrolling," he remarked. "There are
less on subway cars since the attack, which is
why there's so much more panhandling."
Ewing even noted
a "crackdown" in prostitution
in Queens Plaza, where it had become rampant for
some time. A 22-year old Greenpeace recruiter claimed
a similar crackdown might be in effect regarding
narcotics. "It just seems like drugs are actually
harder to get these days," he commented, and
quickly added, "That is, if one were looking
to buy drugs..."
Perhaps people have simply become oblivious of
late to anything other than body counts, war games
and an oncoming recession. Or maybe most just want
the warm and fuzzy friendliness of unity and support
for a broken city untainted by everyday vice.
"I can easily see two kinds of arguments,
the first being that police are so busy dealing
with hoaxes and scares that the streets are less
patrolled and the risk of an offender is diminished,
which would lead to an increase in crime," explained
Alfred Blumstein, author of The Crime Drop in America. "This
suggests a rationality of 'oh, there's less patrol‹let's
go out and commit more crime,' which does not characterize
most criminal behavior.
"In the other direction." he continued, "there
has been a sense of coming together, patriotism
and feeling good about each other, which would
bring about a decrease. And maybe people are feeling
nice, but drug dealers desperately needing money
might be oblivious to anything other than the compulsion
to sell drugs." Furthermore, he said, anxieties
about terrorism may, in fact, contribute to a potential
rise in drug use.
Yet Blumstein's
latter argument of people "feeling
nice" seems to reflect the assumptions of
many New Yorkers‹even as this premise essentially
conflicts with the facts provided by law enforcement
officials. Many, it seems, would like to believe
even criminals have ceased to think bad thoughts
other than those perpetuated by a common enemy‹that
singular, faceless source of iniquity called Terrorism.
"There seem to be fewer incidents now, less
community complaints of violence compared to what
I dealt with before," said Mamadou Cisse,
Director of Operations at the St. Augustine homeless
shelter in Midtown Manhattan. "A lot of our
clients, the homeless, they get into drugs, and
they used to fight each other pretty badly. I don't
call it a good thing, but if we can find a positive
effect of the tragedy, it's that we kind of care
about each other now...they're not slashing each
other. They're kind of nicer. Some people go to
jail for smoking crack, but that was happening
before September 11.
"They watch the news too, like everyone else," he
continued. "They have the same fears‹'will
I get anthrax? Will there be another attack?' And
they want to help each other through this."
Some contradictions call for explanation, of which
there is some. As of last week, police have increased
patrolling of certain areas to curb the rise in
street crime, particularly the sale of narcotics.
"In September my teams were assigned to various
details related to the World Trade Center attacks,
but as we noticed a rise in drug dealing, they've
been making a lot more arrests lately," remarked
Manhattan North's detective. He alleged that a
barrage of summonses have also been issued over
the past two weeks for unlicensed peddlers, who
are "out in force, and finally being penalized."
|