New York, New
York! The city so nice they named it twice." So
begins a taped message in a New York cab
asking you to fasten your seat belt. For
a city almost entirely sculpted by human
hands, where nature is confined to strictly
defined enclaves, it is amazing how much
love and loyalty it commands. Some hate
it, of course, but they are a very small
minority and are unlikely to take kindly
to any urban environment. The vast majority
falls deeply in love with it and never
recovers. Like London and Paris, New York
is a city of great vitality and so full
of varied life that no one can remain indifferent
to it. A true world city, its streets are
full of people from different parts and
cultures jostling each other and a babble
of tongues makes not cacophony but harmonious
international music. Take a cab and you
will find that the driver's mother tongue
is Punjabi or, perhaps, Spanish rather
than English. That would be rare even in
London where you are unlikely to understand
the cabbie because he speaks nothing but
cockney.
As
the world capital of finance, whatever happens here
has repercussions around the globe. If Wall Street
sneezes, bourses around the world start shivering.
For businessmen and entrepreneurs, the attractions
of the city are obvious. But others flock to it too.
Talent is drawn to it from all parts of the world--fashion
designers, dependent on an ambience of wealth, artists
who thrive on a plentiful supply of collectors and
connoisseurs, actors and playwrights who cannot prosper
without a well developed theater. New York pulls them
all in because it has so much to offer them and, in
turn, gains from their creativity. It becomes more
than a merely urban community. It becomes a truly urbane
one.
It was the same more than 30 years ago when I
came to this city for my first stay. There was
the same bustle, the same intensity of life, the
same energy that had made it the center of the
world of finance and commerce. The museums displayed
the works of the world's greatest artists, on Broadway
one could see fresh interpretations of Hamlet,
publishers produced books that excited the imagination
and educated the intellect. And it had one of the
world's truly great libraries. Even so, the city
was not entirely free of problems. The west side
was in rapid and apparently unstoppable decline.
Behind the sparkle of Times Square there was something
seedy and squalid that gave the area an unsavory
reputation. People warned you about dark streets
and the constant threat of mugging. It is instructive
to remember that because it makes one aware of
what this city's vigor and determination have achieved.
The apparently impossible has been done and West
42nd Street cleaned up. The West Side is undergoing
a renaissance and though it is unlikely that crime
will disappear anywhere forever, New Yorkers and
their mayor have done a lot to improve this aspect
of city life. Along the way there may have been
some indiscretions but the courts have dealt with
the issues of civic rights that have arisen. And
this, indeed, is what democracy is all about. It
does not, after all, guarantee that incorrect decisions
will not be made but ensures that when that happens
there will be institutions which will act to correct
executive excess and guide society back along the
paths laid down by law.
As is evident, much has been achieved but some
problems have proved too intractable even for New
York. What is a cause for increasing concern in
any country struggling to develop its economy at
a rapid pace is inexcusable in one of the richest
cities in the world. One wondered 30 years ago
if people in stretch limousines could see through
their darkened windows that there were people sleeping
on flattened cardboard boxes in Fifth Avenue doorways
in freezing winter. One continues to wonder why
the best in human economic ingenuity has not been
able to devise a way out of such intolerable poverty
even after all these years. One wonders not only
because the city and the country surely has enough
to go round for all but also because the generosity
of the American people is beyond dispute. This
is attested to not only by the soup kitchens and
food pantries at which the indigent line up every
day but also by the fact that it was Marshall Aid
that put Europe back on its feet after the Second
World War and has done so much to try and bring
a measure of well-being to others around the globe
who had achieved freedom from colonial rule.
Thirty years ago, as the festive season approached
and we went along the streets, my son's eyes, wide
in wonder, glittered in the lights. The lights
heralding the holiday shopping season are lit again,
as they were then, but they seem to be less lustrous
today. September 11 and the anthrax scare are,
of course, partly responsible for that. The fact
that the United States is now the sole super power
has, indeed, altered the context in which New York
has its being; but instead of a feeling of greater
confidence and strength there seems to be an awareness
of vulnerability, of being under siege. Even with
Soviet missiles pointed at the United States, New
York did not seem so inflicted with anxiety. One
has the feeling that neither the impending total
defeat of the Taliban in Afghanistan nor the arrest
of Osama bin Laden will quite change that. New
Yorkers are now apprehensive about an enemy that
is more difficult to deal with than any they have
known in the past because it is more amorphous,
less easy to identify, who can act without regard
to the usual norms and is, therefore, practically
impossible to guard against totally.
In moments of great tension people seek relief.
That is what festivities are for. However there
is no escaping the economic downturn, now officially
recognized as recession. Lost jobs, increasing
unemployment, lowered expectations, are all enforcing
a frugality unusual during the recent years of
plenty. Less spending means slower business in
a city whose economy has been badly damaged by
the attack on the World Trade Center and its effects
are traveling in ever widening ripples to other
parts of the United States and the shores of distant
lands. Even New York, it appears, needs to have
its morale boosted. The world, it seems, must do
what it can to reassure this great city, not only
for the sake of New York itself but even more so
because so much in the rest of the world depends
on its self confidence.
The world has, indeed, tried to demonstrate that
it continues to repose its trust in this mega polis.
The leaders of the world did not shy away from
the UN General Assembly session despite the possibility
of a follow-up terrorist attack. They gathered
in defiance of the criminals to condemn in no uncertain
terms the outrage perpetrated on New York. The
General Assembly of the UN is an annual event and
world leaders come to attend it every year but
what could be a greater vote of confidence in New
York and its future than the decision to hold another
event of enormous world significance here.
The World Economic Forum, which has regularly
brought together statesmen, entrepreneurs and economic
managers in Davos, Switzerland, will hold its next
meeting in New York next January. The interaction
between the different players in the economic arena,
people who have different roles to play and different
constituencies to answer to, is of great importance
to the world's economic health. To be able to view
the economic situation from different vantage points
and to discuss the possible actions that can be
taken in different spheres is to be able to coordinate
action and ensure a healthy growth of world economy.
Too often economists and economic managers sound
as if they regarded profits, growth and wealth
as ultimate goals, as ends in themselves. The problem
with such a view is that the human being is lost
sight of; it is forgotten that the human being
is not only the subject but also the object of
the economy and it is for the welfare of the people
that economic growth and increased wealth is sought.
In sheltered Davos, where affluent skiers gather
in winter, it may have been easy to lose sight
of the problems faced by the ordinary, vulnerable
individual. Here in New York, the participants
of the forum may catch a glimpse of the homeless
and the hungry as they drive past on their way
to or from their meeting places and spare a thought
for devising policies and methods that will give
to them a life of dignity, not one dependent on
charity.
|