Moscow-- After close to two hours
of discussion, a panel at the World Economic Forum's
(WEF) Russia Meeting 2001 reached a frustrating conclusion
yesterday afternoon: Russia lacks venture capitalism
During
the past two days more than 400 high-level business,
political, cultural and academic minds from around
the world discussed the state of Russia's investment
climate and explored topics including attracting foreign
investment and fostering World Trade Organization (WTO)
accession. Approximately 50 participants attended a
workshop held yesterday entitled 'How to Become a Great
Russian Entrepreneur,' which looked at a new generation
of Russian business leaders.
Moderated by Alexei Pushkov, an author and program
director of TV Center in Russia, 'How to Become
a Great Russian Entrepreneur' left participants
a little weary about the state of venture capitalism
in Russia.
"There is little to nothing in the way of
venture capitalists in Russia right now," said
Jack Barbanel, President and CEO of Strategic Investment
Group, an investment banking and private equity
firm based in Moscow. "Russia has many brilliant
minds in the area of science and that's all you
hear about. It lacks the people to be the CEOs
and to fill other head management positions."
The panel discussed
the fact that there is no shortage of financial
risks being taken in Russia.
The problem lies in the number of risks that turn
out successful."There is venture, but not
venture capitalism," said L.Craig Johnstone,
Vice-President of The Boeing Company.
One participant
identified the majority of venture capitalists
as non-Russians. "The venture
capitalists are young kids from the UK who've lost
their jobs and come here," said Barbanel.
Participants agreed
that with reforms moving forward and an improving
investment climate, the time for
venture capitalism is better than ever. "There
are some very lucrative areas out there," said
Johnstone. "I was sitting next to three men
who started out with a couple thousand dollars
and now are billionaires. Now is the time for venture
capitalism, people just have to be clever and patient."
Bruce Nasby, Senior
Vice-President of Students in Free Enterprise,
an educational center that
teaches free market capitalism to students worldwide,
agreed that the opportunities for venture capitalism
in Russia are out there. "First and foremost,
we need to get away from the old business mentality.
We need to spread the idea of free market enterprise."
While participants
identified Russia's current lack of successful
venture capitalism as a problem,
many were hopeful for the future. "As Russia's
economy grows stronger, we hope to see a strong
wave of venture capitalism arise," said Barbanel.
|