CAIRO--Dr. Shaban Abou El-Fotoh
is very proud of the gold stars he has been awarded
by Egypt's Ministry of Health and displays them
proudly on the wall of his office in the Hegazy
Medical Center, a public clinic in the town of
Caliobeya, just outside of Cairo. He was awarded
these stars based on his management of the clinic,
a clean but basic facility that receives more
than 300 patients a day and serve four local
neighborhoods that comprise of over 27,000 residents.
El-Fotoh and many of the nurses, physicians and
technicians in the center have received supplemental
medical training from a program spearheaded by
Egyptian anthropologist Dr. Hind Khattab in conjunction
with the United Nations Population Fund's Cairo
field office. Her program was established to
improve the quality and sensitivity of reproductive
health care services in rural Egypt.
The
Hegazy Medical Center is one of a handful of clinics
near Cairo involved in Khattab's pilot program
that has been so successful in its results that
UNFPA decided to continue supporting it in its
new program for 2002-2006. The idea for the program
was born in 1988, when Khattab attended a conference
on maternal mortality. She wanted to understand
why women in Egypt, as well as many other developing
nations, were not aware of their gynecological
health and effectively suffer in silence. For example,
56 percent of Egyptian women suffered from collapsed
uterus, due to constant squatting, carrying and
home deliveries. As a result, Khattab and colleagues
undertook a community-based study where they knocked
at hundreds of doors in a rural Egyptian area,
asked women about their health and took them to
a clinic to run some lab tests for them. What they
found was a large percentage of women who did not
go to clinics to examine their female morbidities
due to social and economic reasons.
She
approached women with the message: "It's
our right to care about our bodies."
"Young women in particular, who feel powerless
in the family hierarchy, have a tendency to downplay
their own health problems," according to Khattab.
Physicians, she said, were not aware of some of
the morbidities women carry. This was due, in part,
to a failure of physicians and health care workers
who did not make an effort to understand women
and their health problems. Khattab explained that
the medical system lacked an emphasis on counseling
and approaching womenís health in a holistic
manner.
"We thought that physicians training is lacking
somewhere and observed the problems of the organizational
structure of the health centers," said Khattab.
She added that physicians also take on a managerial
task without any background and that nurses and
technicians lack the adequate training. Khattab
said she was one of the few people that believed
that management is essential in running any health
center. Physicians need to have an understanding
of what management is so they can respond to everyday
problems, according to Khattab.
Back
at the Hegazy Medical Center, El-Fotoh proudly
showed Earthtimes
around the clinic. The walls
there are bare except for the occasional posters
featuring diagrams explaining common diseases and
contraceptive usage. Despite the clinical look
of the place, it is warm and friendly. Patients,
who pay around $1 USD for their clinic visit, collected
tickets at the door and waited patiently to be
seen by a nurse or doctor. Many patients in the
clinic during the Earthtimes visit were waiting
for injections. But for those who came in for consultations,
doctors and nurses took the time to talk to patients
and explain to them how to use their medications
and how to monitor their and their children's health.
El-Fotoh said Khattab and her NGO, the Egyptian
Society for Population Studies, have worked to
change the behaviors of the centerís staff,
making them emphasize their social interaction
with patients in addition to their physical examinations.
Khattab
said that it was not enough just to improve these
health
care facilities, but to make people
use them. "If we make the place humanly acceptable,
what else should we do?" she said rhetorically. "We
can not work just improving health service providers,
we must create a demand for services available."
Hegazy clinic certainly seemed in high demand.
Its corridors were filled with patients walking
in and out of offices. One young gynecologist,
trained by Dr. Khattab, noted that more and more
women have been coming to the center to obtain
contraception and advice on the proper forms of
contraception to use. Many of them, she said, were
very knowledgeable about the different forms of
contraception available to them and she has noticed
in the past decade that more and more of her patients
are only having between two to three children.
Dr. Layla Assad Farad, a pediatrician at Hegazy,
also received training from Khattab. She said that
she was trained to promote the use of contraception
after labor. She has been counseling both husband
and wife on post-natal contraception, and according
to her training, has instructed the husbands to
use condoms while their wives use the loop method.
To
maintain the sustainability of the project, Khattab
decided
to engage the support of Egypt's
Ministry of Health and Population. She enlisted
their support from day one and began to train them. "There
was a period where we gave them the skills to take
over everything," she explained. "We
were training a nucleus of physicians, nurses and
lab technicians so they could be the future trainers,
and we succeeded in doing that. They now do the
training themselves." Khattab and her team
now monitor and evaluate the MOHP training.
The
UNFPA's support of Khattab's program reflects
their emphasis
on non-traditional approaches towards
population issues. Dr. Faysal Abdel Gadir Mohamed,
the Sudanese director of the UNFPA field office
in Cairo, said that in the past 10 to15 years,
there has been a rapid increase in modernization,
which has dramatically increased the means of communication
available in rural area. "People have started
to question things more--the Koran, their health," said
Gadir. "People want to understand more, like
a child being exposed to the outside world who
naturally questions what he begins to see." This
has led to a change in approach to population issues,
he said. UNFPA is focusing its efforts on two main
areas: reproductive health and population and development.
Egypt used to be classified as country A, but
because of the improvements in past 12-15 years
Egypt moved into B and C. As a result, the field
office no longer handles direct support services
or constructing health centers. Gadir explained
that they now work in capacity development, advising
health centers, and working with NGOs. Egypt has
to deal with a major population challenge. With
an estimated population of 65.1 million, fertility
in Egypt had been on a decline starting in the
mid-1980s. For the past 10 years it remained at
a plateau, but Gadir noted that the trend is currently
reversing slightly. Today, 37 percent of Egypt's
population is under age 15 and growth is now projected
in Egypt until 2025. By 2030, it is estimated that
the population of Egypt will reach 120 million.
Lubna
Baqi, Deputy Director of the UNFPA field office,
said that
their support of Khattab's project
is essential to their program's mission, particularly
in the area of young people. Almost 1/3 of Egypt
is considered youth and marriage in Egypt is young
(most people marry by the age of 20). In most cases,
young couples conceive soon after marriage and
know little about reproductive health. "We
want to give them more information and provide
an environment where people can seek counseling
and advice," said Baqi. Baqi added that supporting
Dr. Khattab's work is an innovative project for
UNFPA. "We are trying to use the experience
of that project and create awareness of why it
is a useful approach and what application it has
for the health sector," she added. It has
already been successful in reforming the health
sector on a small scale by improving the quality
of health care, sensitive counseling, and understanding
womenís broader health needs. These changes,
according to Baqi, are difficult to make, and she
has already been successful in accomplishing those
goals. And unlike other UNFPA-supported projects,
Khattab conducts her projects on a low budget.
Due
to the success of the pilot program in Egypt,
Khattab believes
this success can be transferred
to other countries. Women, who have benefited from
the program, are the program's best advocates.
The project, or the Giza study, started as a reproductive
health-working group, with participants from Jordan,
Syria, Sudan, and Lebanon. UNFPA sent an evaluating
team to evaluate Dr. Khattab's program. Based on
their evaluation, UNFPA said they would like to
replicate it wherever they could. Khattab maintained
that this program has universal application and
isn't specialized just for the Middle East region. "Religion
has nothing to do with it except it backs up the
project," Khattab said. She said that religious
backing from Islamic leaders gave her program more
credibility. "I don't know why people think
that Islamic societies have a different approach
to health," Khattab said. "I was in many
countries of the world--women are women no matter
where they areóno matter what the religion.
Why should we put those social barriers in doing
anything?"
Khattab spent significant amounts of time working
in India and a Navajo reservation in the United
States. She said that the type of training she
has designed is so flexible, that it changes according
to the needs of the communities she works with.
What her work comes down to is basic human capacity
building and proving her results by success. She
recalled an incident in which a gynecologist, in
the middle of a training session questioned why
he needed to learn about the social components
of health care. Three months later, in another
session, he got up and apologized to Dr. Khattab,
when he revealed that he began to see things through
his mother's eyes. He told Khattab about his mother,
who was subject to an operation years ago. Though
the operation was a success, his mother told him
that it was not the surgeon who saved her life,
but another young physician who looked after her
everyday, talked to her and counseled her. So far,
Khattab has been successful in conveying the importance
of the social sensitivity of medicine in a few
sectors in Egypt. It is just a matter of time before
she can spread this success elsewhere.
|