UNITED
NATIONS - Anyone who is acquainted with cautious
Martti Ahtisaari, serious, hard-working Sadako
Ogata and cheerful, chatty Cornelio Sommaruga
must find it hard to see in them potential leaders
of
a lynch mob. But this, apparently, was Israel's
fear as it reversed a decision to cooperate in
a UN investigation of the events at Jenin, a
West Bank refugee camp run by the world body.
The
trio are the core members of the fact-finding mission
appointed by Secretary General Kofi Annan. In the
absence of any hope of a compromise with the Jerusalem
government on terms for the inquiry that would
be acceptable to the UN, Annan proposed to disband
the team effective Thursday.
Meanwhile, first reports
of the carnage inside
the camp during a week-long
Israeli military occupation
now seem to have been
exaggerated. The latest
Palestinian estimates
have come closer to
those of the Israelis
for the numbers of
dead and wounded on
both sides.
Annan said Wednesday
the fact that there
now was unlikely to
be any independent
investigation cast
a long shadow on Jenin,
and in the wider world,
Israel's U-turn is
likely to harm its
already tarnished image
before the court of
international public
opinion. It was, after
all, its principal
ally the US that sponsored
the Security Council
resolution that authorized
the UN inquiry.
Israel claims that
the camp, which housed
between 14,000 and
15,000 destitute Palestinians,
was a hotbed of terrorism
and that the UN agency
running it did nothing
to stop their murderous
plots.
As Ahtisaari, the
former president of
Finland; Mrs. Ogata,
former UN High Commissioner
for Refugees; and Sommaraga,
former president of
the International Committee
of the Red Cross, cooled
their heels in Geneva
waiting formal ordes
to pack up and go home,
Israel expected a bid,
by the Arab states,
to have the Security
Council force an inquiry.
Paradoxically, the
US was likely to block
such an attempt, using
the veto if necessary.
Israel's
UN delegate Yehuda
Lancry said, "We
trust in the US --
and its commitments
vis a vis Israel --
to oppose such an initiative."
US ambassador John
Negroponte was low-key
in his initial response
to the news of Jerusalem's
snub to the UN and,
by extension, to Washington.
Let's not look at the
rejection of fact-finders
in isolation from positive
developments that show
the power of American
diplomacy, he said.
Not precisely in those
words, but this was
his meaning.
Prime Minister Ariel
Sharon's tough line
against a Jenin inquiry
can win him few admirers
in most countries that
prize human rights
and fundamental freedoms,
however vehemently
he may protest that
Israel was unjustly
accused and that the
UN has unfairly turned
a blind eye toward
suicide bombings that
killed Israeli civilians.
But his stance is warmly
applauded at home.
No Israeli politician
is likely to lose votes
for standing up to
the widely despised
UN, which has a history
of one-sided resolutions
on every aspect of
the Middle East conflict.
The
sorry episode is
especially sad for
Kofi Annan, who has
taken to addressing
the Israelis as "my
friends" and was
instrumental in getting
Israel accepted into
the Western nations
caucus after the Asian
members would have
no truck with the Jewish
state. (The Secretary
General is not a person
who bears a grudge
and he's likely to
write off the Jenin
affair off as something
that comes with the
territory.)
Unfazed by Israeli
intransigence, Annan
was off to Washington
Thursday for a meeting
of the Middle East
Quartet, comprising
top representatives
of the US, Russia,
the European Union
and the UN.
ILL NEWS FROM ZIMBABWE
Richard Williamson,
the US ambassador for
special political affairs
to the UN, deserves
praise for standing
up to the autocratic
president of Zimbabwe,
Robert Mugabe. Visiting
Harare, the capital,
with a 15-nation team
of UN Security Council
members trying to promote
peace in the Great
Lakes region of Africa.
Williamson told Mugabe
that his vicious harassment
of the media was unacceptable
to the US. He also
questioned the circumstances
of the president's
recent re-election,
which followed violence
against opposition
candidates and their
supporters.
A Reuters dispatch
reported that an angry
exchange lasting several
minutes ensued and
that Mugabe rejoined
that he hasn't accepted
that George W. Bush
won the US presidential
election.
In
what may or may not
have been a followup
to the incident, Andrew
Meldrum, an American
journalist who is one
of the few Western
correspondents left
in Zimbabwe, was arrested
Wednesday and accused
of abusing his professional "privileges" and
publishing false information.
The arrest followed
the detention on similar
charges Tuesday of
Collin Chiwanza and
Lloyd Mudiwa, reporters
for The Daily News,
the country's only
independent newspaper.
Its editor, Geoffrey
Nyarota, has been selected
by an international
jury as the winner
of this year's World
Press Freedom Prize,
which was instituted
by Unesco. He was arrested
two weeks ago after
reporting that the
presidential election
results were doctored.
Two other journalists,
Iden Wetherell and
Dumisani Muleya, were
also detained two weeks
ago and later released,
in the government crackdown
on the media.
Meanwhile, Unesco,
which organizes the
annual celebration
of World Press Freedom
Day -- it falls this
Friday -- is alarmed
that governments may
be seizing an opportunity
to apply restrictions
on the press that have
long been held in abeyance,
using the Sept. 11
terror attacks as the
rationale.
The Paris-based UN
agency mentioned media
curbs proposed or approved
in Australia, Britain,
Canada, Cyprus, France,
India, Jordan, Uganda
and the US, and by
the 15-nation European
Union. Also, of course,
in Zimbabwe.
|