UNITED
NATIONS - Here they go again, bashing the messenger.
And, to make things worse, one of our own doing
the bashing. Barbara Pyle, a former vice president
of Turner Broadcasting, complains that the media
ignore the natives except when it's to report
something negative about them.
The
term natives is used here for what the UN calls
indigenous people. The Organization just began
a two-week discussion about the problems they confront
in today's fast-paced world where the cleft stick
gave way long ago to telegrams, that in turn were
displaced by e-mail, and homes with central heating
and Jacuzzis are preferred over huts clad with
the skins of animals, and igloos. Also, to give
them credit for "their invaluable contribution" to
the world.
Not to be cynical,
but some may consider
this an exercise of
questionable merit,
considering the many
other pressing matters
of peace and war there
are to worry about.
But no. It turns out
to be the first session
of yet another UN entity
most folks may be unaware
of, namely the Permanent
Forum on Indigenous
Issues.
For
reasons unexplained,
the maligned media
blamed for not reporting
on "indigenous
issues" will be
allowed into the proceedings
on a basis "yet
to be determined," although
they were permitted
a peek at the opening
meeting.
For anyone who follows
the news, it may seem
that many indigenous
people have a problem
remaining indigenous.
They can't wait to
wander, thousands of
them risking life and
limb to get to someplace
else. But the UN chooses
to regard them, en
masse, as delicately
exotic creatures whose
cultures must be nurtured
and protected and kept
from an exposure to
the 21st century that
they themselves in
many cases seem to
seek.
"Indigenous peoples
have not been able
to represent their
own interests directly
to any major body of
the UN," states
a background note about
the Forum, whose "eight
indigenous experts
will advise and report
directly to the Economic
and Social Council."
Ah,
ECOSOC. After years
of serving as
a poor relation among
UN bodies, the Council
is on a bit of a roll
and this is just one
more thing it has gotten
into. "In addition
to advising the Council,
the Forum has been
asked to raise awareness,
promote the integration
and coordination of
activities relating
to indigenous issues
within the UN system
and disseminate information
on indigenous issues," the
background note explains.
It will be news to
many, but it seems
we are all well into
the International Decade
of the World's Indigenous
People, which the UN
proclaimed in 1995.
The current exercise
in a forum that the
planners expected to
attract 600 or more
participants is part
of the 10-year-long
proceedings.
It
seems that some indigenous
people are
more equal than others,
and many of them (most
in all likelihood)
get to speak only as "observers," not
full delegates. Rules
of procedure is an
item on the agenda
and the rules finally
agreed upon will guide
the conduct of future
sessions and determine
who shall or shall
not contribute to the
debate.
Human rights are involved,
of course, in the treatment
of what used to be
called native minorities
by majorities presumed
not to be indigenous,
no matter how settled
and how many generations
of ancestry they may
trace.
Mary Robinson, who
is scheduled to step
down in September as
the UN High Commissioner
for Human Rights, came
to New York for the
Forum and joined Barbara
Pyle in the discussions
about the alleged shortcomings
of news media unwilling
to unable to spot the
positive stories in
the indigenous life.
She
recommended that "indigenous
media" fill the
gap and eventually "ensure
that the mainstream
media hear and understand
the points you are
making."
"It's good," she
said, "to be a
voice for indigenous
people, and it's necessary,
but it's also necessary
to get indigenous issues
into the mainstream
of media and communications."
Looking
at the matter from
a different critical
angle, it could be
argued that the UN
has set its sights
too low and that the
Forum is a pathetically
inadequate response
to problems out there
that may go unrecognized.
Official estimates
put the number of "indigenous
groups" at 5,000,
embracing 300 million
people living in more
than 70 countries and
5 continents.
Their "invaluable
contribution to the
survival of humankind" led
the UN to proclaim
this international
decade, the background
note advises.
|