WASHINGTON--World
Bank President James Wolfensohn and British finance
minister Gordon Brown have both called recently
for major increases in foreign aid. Brown would
like to see aid from the worldís leading
industrial countries double to $100 million a
year. Wolfensohn and Brown are right to seize
the opportunity
of post-September 11 concern about the stability
of developing countries to make their proposals.
But, if aid is increased, then how should it
be used?
There
are important claimants on more aid, from those who
wish to see major boosts in spending on health and
education, to those who want a greater aid focus on
poorer Asian, Middle Eastern and African countries.
Unquestionably, in light of recent events, there will
be strong pressures to devote more aid to building
democracy in many parts of the world. Within this context
it is surely time for the bilateral and multilateral
aid agencies to assign priority to strengthening press
freedom.
An effective and independent press is crucial
in building a world where there is greater
understanding of differing views, great tolerance
for dissent, greater transparency in the
ways of government and greater public accountability
by politicians and civil servants. And, actions
to strengthen the press are now urgent in
many parts of the world.
In Afghanistan, where there is barely a
functioning domestic media, and across the
border in Pakistan where courageous journalists
face daily pressures, building democracy
will depend in part on securing a credible
press. In Botswana, where political leadership
is threatening to license journalists, and
across the border in Zimbabwe where a dictator
has smashed a free press, the valiant and
excellent journalists of these countries
now need support. Efforts to strengthen the
press are vital today in Peru, where massive
corruption has tainted media owners, and
across the border in Colombia where reporters
are being murdered as they investigate crime
and corruption.
A central function of a free press is to
investigate and expose corruption and recent
events have underlined the relationships
between corrupt governments and terrorist
organizations. Terrorism, for example, has
been all too evident in many of the countries
perceived (according to the Transparency
International Corruption Perceptions Index)
to have very high levels of governmental
corruption, such as Pakistan, Russia, Tanzania,
Ukraine, Azerbaijan, Bolivia, Cameroon, Kenya,
Indonesia, Uganda, Nigeria and Bangladesh.
Censorship
in different forms is widespread in many
developing countries and provides
cover for the corrupt practices of government
leaders. Insufficient efforts are being made
by Western aid agencies to pressure the recipients
of aid to reduce censorship and strengthen
transparency. Most governments use the pretext
of ìnational security,î for
example, to curb all public discussion and
knowledge of defense spending and arms imports.
The international arms trade is a major area
of grand corruption and the excessive use
of ìnational securityî places
ever more weapons in the hands of dictators
and opens the gates to weapons supplies to
terrorist organizations. It hides illicit
trade in diamonds, gold and other natural
resources that finance arms purchases and
support both the growth of terrorist organizations
and the enrichment of corrupt politicians
and military leaders.
So what practical actions can be taken?
I believe the time is right and the opportunity
present to strongly encourage adoption of
a 10 point action agenda, consisting of the
following:-
Bilateral
and multilateral aid agencies should forge
grand coalitions at regional
and global levels to promote excellent journalism ñ coalitions
involving governmental agencies in partnership
with business, private foundations, media
organizations and other civil society groups.
The coalitions should support aggressive
programs to train journalists, and media
owners and managers in developing countries.
At the core of training programs should be
the encouragement of ethical approaches designed
to boost integrity in all uses of the media.
Leaders in developing countries must be
encouraged to support press freedom, counter
all forms of censorship, and recognize the
need for independent judges and public prosecutors
to guarantee press freedom.
Coalition
partners need to campaign against censorship
(against physical intimidation
of the media, against vicious libel actions,
and against excessive governmental use of
the term ìnational securityî).
Aid agencies
and philanthropic foundations should strengthen
financial support for civil
society organizations dedicated to building
a free press ñ these organizations
need to be the on-the-ground leaders in strengthening
capacities to secure effective media.
Aid agencies should assign greater overall
priority in their dialogues with countries
to supporting programs and projects to strengthen
the media.
Aid agencies should devote more financial
resources for this purpose and recruit more
experts with knowledge of journalism and
media management.
Aid agencies
should emphasize in ëgood
governanceí program negotiations with
officials in developing countries the need
to build institutions to support a free and
independent media, and assure freedom of
information on all aspects of public policy.
These programs should promote the development
of laws to guarantee press freedom.
Governments in developing countries should
be encouraged to promote the development
of strong private media enterprises and adopt
laws to ensure media competition.
Research should be undertaken to determine
the most effective means to financially support
competitive media firms, to secure adequate
resources to pay journalists decently, to
support investigative journalism, and to
explore the potential of Internet news media.
We live in a world of constant security
dangers. A safer world, where the prospects
for accelerated human development is possible,
calls for greater tolerance among peoples,
greater understanding of differing perspectives
and greater public support for governmental
institutions. But establishing vibrant democracies
challenges the comfortable and corrupt elites
in many nations that profit from political
systems that are largely secret. Critical
to challenging these systems is the strengthening
of the media and the time has surely come
when development assistance agencies should
take the firm lead to make a major contribution
on this front.
|