ROME--On
the old Continent it was early afternoon
when the terrorists struck at the Twin
Towers and the Pentagon on that Tuesday
morning. European television networks
interrupted their programs to show the
first pictures of the horror. Some European
viewers cried, others thought for a few
moments they were seeing a science-fiction
movie of aliens attacking Earth.
During
the following hours and days it was hard to place a
phone call to New York. All circuits were overloaded
as uncounted people wanted reassurance that relatives
and friends had weathered the ordeal--or callers just
felt the need to say, "We are with you." Europe's
most powerful emotional response to events in the United
States since the assassination of President Kennedy
in 1963 showed the innumerable public and private bonds
that tie it to America, and especially to New York.
A plaque on the Romanesque-Gothic cathedral
of Piacenza near Milan records that the Famiglia
Piacentina of New York, a hometown association,
donated replacement of a gilt angel sculpture
that a World War II bombing raid had knocked
off the bell tower. Basques, Greeks, Estonians
and scores of other ethnic communities too have
their own social or parish organizations, clubs
and restaurants in Big Apple. You hail a taxi
at Penn Station and the woman cabbie informs
you during the ride that she recently immigrated
from Romania. Spaniards who remember the Civil
War of 1936-39 still live on West 14th Street
in Manhattan, not far from Ground Zero. And among
the Holocaust survivors in New York quite grim
memories of the old country are curiously mixed
with something like nostalgia for their pre-Nazi
days there.
Then there are the multitudes of Europeans who
are or have recently been in New York as tourists
for New Year's Eve in Times Square or to visit
the museums and pick up bargains in the stores,
or for longer sojourns as students or for business.
On the other hand, Oxford and Paris and Salamanca
and Florence are full of young Americans who
spend an academic year there; and tens of thousands
of retirees or other expatriates from the United
States have made their home in some European
country.
Almost all of these people, their families,
friends and hosts wanted to talk to one another.
And thus clogged the trans-Atlantic phone networks.
There
were also high-priority communications. One
of the first
was from Tony Blair to the White
House. The Prime Minister told President Bush
first, and the American people in person at an
address to Congress later, that Britain was standing
shoulder to shoulder with the United States.
The impression throughout Continental Europe
was deep, and it wasn't devoid of some muted
misgivings: Which side are the Brits really on?
The question had often been asked on the Continent
before--Are the British convinced Europeans or
do they, with their "special relationship," represent
a Yank outpost on the east side of the ocean?
The leaders of France, Germany, Italy, Spain
and other European nations quickly followed Blair's
lead, assuring the United States President in
person of their governments' full support in
the war on terrorism. The basic doctrine of the
North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) was
invoked: An armed attack on one of its members
will be considered an attack against all. NATO
countries pledged military help; Britain had
lent it immediately and substantially.
What made even more of a splash in Europe than
Britain's prompt reaction to the terrorist offensive
was the early phone call to President Bush from
the President of the Russian Federation, Vladimir
Putin, offering collaboration. European commentators
pointed out that Putin was thinking in the first
place of Islamist extremists in the Caucasus
and in the Central Asian republics that once
belonged to the Soviet Union. Yet those analysts
also sensed a significant shift in big-power
relations. Russia to them seemed cozying up to
NATO, whose European members had allied themselves
with the United States in 1949 because they felt
threatened by Moscow.
President Putin's gestures after Sept. 11 and
his family visit with the Bushes at their Texas
ranch in November baffled old-line Communists
throughout Europe not a little. Other leftists
who traditionally have regarded the Russians
as an indispensable counterweight to the overbearing
Americans were, and are, equally perplexed.
Already
in the first few days after the Twin Towers
crumbled
some left leaning newspapers
and magazines in France and other European countries
had cautiously but unmistakably gloated. "The
Giant has been Wounded by His Own Weapons" was
a typical headline. In snide commentaries the
United States was reminded of the Iraqi children
whose death the American-inspired embargo had
allegedly caused, and of sundry other misdeeds
the United States was said to have perpetrated
in the third world. What happened in New York
and Washington serves them right, was not the
so subtly expressed message.
When
the first bombs rained on Afghanistan, anti-American
coalitions in various European
cities staged protest marches, meetings and sit-ins. "Neither
for bin Laden nor for Bush" was (and still
is) the alliterative slogan of the demonstrators.
To end terrorism, the protestors recommended
negotiations and dialogue. How to engage religiously
motivated fanatics in constructive talks has
never been explained by the pro-Taliban opinion
makers.
European
opposition to the American anti-terrorism strategies
has
the support of some lawmakers
in various nations and a popular following of
variable breadth. This camp is composed of many
diverse factions: There are Leninist and Stalinist
diehards, sneering intellectuals who regard the
Americans as rich but crude barbarians, anti-war
Greens, anti-Semites and ultra-rightists, and
religiously motivated pacifists. The last group
includes quite a few left-wing Roman Catholics,
some clergy among them. In a village church in
Tuscany at Christmastime worshippers spotted
among the figures of shepherds the likeness of
Osama bin Laden in the traditional Nativity display.
The mutterings of the congregation members who
didn't want to see the Prince of Terror among
the humble folk adoring the Infant Jesus in His
crib caused the offending crèche to be
removed.
The Vatican, which keeps exerting a lot of influence
not only in countries like Italy, Poland and
Ireland but also in France and Germany, was itself
caught in a bind. Pope John Paul II has for some
time been attempting to promote something like
amicable relations with Islam. He recently paid
unprecedented visits to al-Azhar University in
Cairo, the foremost Muslim center of learning,
and to the Mosque of the Omayyads in Damascus;
he has proposed that the followers of Christ
and of the Prophet Muhammad should pardon each
other for past persecutions and atrocities. The
present pontiff has also expressed sympathy for
the Palestinian cause and has repeatedly received
Yasir Arafat in formal audiences.
Catholic
pacifists in Europe therefore expected the
pope to speak
out, condemning the American
and British bombing raids on Afghanistan. However,
prudence prevailed in the Vatican after the Roman
Catholic hierarchy of the United States overwhelmingly
endorsed President Bush and his war on terrorism.
Pope John Paul II, whose public utterances are
frequent, covering many subjects and issues,
has been markedly restrained in discussing what
has been happening in Afghanistan. Meanwhile,
several European nations have stepped up their
own anti terrorism drives. Following the kamikaze
attacks in New York and Washington it was found
that much of the preparations had been done in
places like Hamburg, London, Madrid and Milan.
Islamist extremists evidently had infiltrated
also the scruffy suburbs of French cities that
are populated by immigrants from North Africa
as well as some Muslim mosques and community
centers in England and on the Continent. The
European nations, like Germany, that have imported
millions of "guest workers" from Islamic
countries during the last several decades are
now investigating terrorist conspiracies; they
have discovered that al Qaeda cells managed to
recruit volunteers for violence and even for
suicide missions, and to send them to training
camps in Afghanistan. Clandestine Islamist networks
also appear to have raised plenty of funds, channeling
them to bin Laden's organization through the
awala system, which works through family and
tribal connections and leaves no written records.
Sensitive spots throughout Europe--government
buildings, airports, railroad terminals, tunnels
and bridges, embassies, power plants and other
installations--are now guarded around the clock.
The authorities suspect that bin Laden's web
of terrorism, still largely intact, may be preparing
a major attack somewhere in Britain or on the
Continent. Such a criminal strike may be planned
for more than one plane at the same time, as
it was in the synchronized New York-Washington
action. Sept. 11 also has induced European law
enforcement and intelligence agencies to collaborate
more closely with one another and with their
American counterparts than they did before. Information
regarding terrorism suspects is now exchanged
every day. One of the findings in ongoing investigations
is that the activists of al Qaeda and similar
networks change their ostensible identities and
names frequently and apparently have little difficulty
in getting false passports, money, shelter and
explosives.
All the time European leaders are watching with
dismay the somber developments in the Israeli-Palestinian
conflict, and are nervously hoping that the United
States will not take on Iraq after--or even before--bin
Laden is dealt with. Sept. 11 has deepened Europe's
economic troubles and increased the number of
jobless. What may be the timid beginning of recovery
might be snuffed out by another major war just
as the Continent has achieved an important step
toward unification by the adoption, as of January
1, 2002, of the new 12-nation currency, the euro
|