BONN--Countries
need to take a gender sensitive approach to water
issues by including women in decision making at
all levels, but affirmative action is not enough,
said delegates attending Thursday's plenary session
on gender issues at the Freshwater Conference in
Bonn.
"Gender
is a social, not a biological concept," said keynote
speaker Barbara Schreiner, a representative from South
Africa's Department of Water Affairs and Forestry.
Schreiner said that before it is possible to talk about
gender policies, an understanding of what gender means
is essential.
"We need to understand
gender issues and roles
in order to change
them," she said. "Gender
equity is the process
of being fair to men
and women.and equity
leads to equality."
But even when gender
is taken into account
in making policy, what
seems like a success
story on paper does
not always reflect
the reality on the
ground.
In one United Nations
(UN) project in Africa,
the UN insisted that
at least two women
be involved in each
water project. The
aim was to give women
more control in the
management of water
projects that directly
influenced their communities.
Instead, the two women
that were involved
in each project were
often relegated to
such roles as cleaning
the pumps or keeping
the animals and the
children away from
wells. The data on
inclusion of women
may have looked good
on paper, but the policy
didn't pan out in practice.
But there are success
stories. South Africa
has made progress in
increasing the participation
of women at all levels
in water management.
Government representatives
attribute this increase
to two things: a constitution
that states that gender
equality is a basic
right, and the monitoring
of gender equality
by specific institutions.
Mike Muller, director
of South Africa's Ministry
of Water Affairs and
Forestry, said that
gender equality is
even taken into account
when high-powered international
companies bid for contracts.
"When companies
tender for a bid, the
number of women on
the board of that company
helps to determine
whether that company
gets the contract or
not," said Muller.
Trinidad and Tobago
has had its own success
story.
"All of our community
water projects have
been started and run
by women, and that
is why they work!" said
Robert Salandy, Deputy
Director of the Land
and Water Development
Division of the Ministry
of Food Production
and Maritime Resources.
But while Trinidad
and Tobago can boast
of this success, and
most agree that women
need to play a greater
role in water management
at all levels, some
water experts stressed
the importance of including
men in the gender discussion.
"Gender is not
just about including
more women," said
a delegate from Sweden.
Speaking at a press
conference later in
the day, one of the
co-chairs of the event,
Diane M. Quarless,
Jamaica's Deputy Permanent
Representative to the
UN, said that 70 percent
of the students at
universities in her
country are women.
"There are actually
programs that address
the marginalization
of the male," she
said, which brought
chuckles from the audience.
But according to some
experts, excluding
men from programs that
empower women is no
joke.
"What needs to
be done is to empower
men.the entire (gender)
policy is misguided," said
Bhanu R. Neupane, a
representative of the
UNESCO World Water
Assessment Program. "The
men need to be educated
(too). It isn't the
women who are beating
up other women for
not bringing water
home."
Neupane applauded
the programs that educate
women, but would like
to see men being educated
at the same time.
"We are messing
up the social fabric
if we educate only
the women," he
said, warning that
by focusing only on
educating the women,
the men may begin to
feel less empowered
because their wives
know more than them.
Neupane also said
that men need to be
taught that by helping
women in traditional
female roles they are
not giving up their
manhood.
"By working in
the kitchen, I am not
a woman," he said.
Another point that
came up at the meeting
was the decentralization
of water management
and the inclusion of
the people who face
the worst water problems-the
poor.
"Poverty doesn't
relate to stupidity," said
Schreiner. "Poor
men and women do have
voices, they know what
they want to say."
Behind the policy
prescriptions that
resulted from the meeting,
delegates made sure
that a human face was
put on the issue. One
delegate from Brazil
reminded attendees
why it was so important
to address the issue
of gender equality
in water issues. She
spoke of an arid region
of Brazil where women
walk eight kilometers
a day to fetch water,
explaining that when
a woman from this region
turns 65, she will
have spend one-third
of her life getting
water. By freeing women
from this labor, she
said, they can do other
things that will benefit
themselves and their
communities. And those
pushing to address
gender issues when
it comes to water management
agree that helping
people help themselves
is what it is all about.
|