Energy | Nature

ANALYSIS:Bid or bluff as the EU plays climate-change poker?

Luxembourg - If you want poker players to show you their cards, you have to put your own hand on the table first. That was the philosophy which led the European Union on Wednesday to publish a near-complete set of demands for United Nations climate-c...
Posted : Wed, 21 Oct 2009 15:16:44 GMT
By : dpa
Category : Environment
News Alerts by Email ( click here )
Environment News | Home
Luxembourg - If you want poker players to show you their cards, you have to put your own hand on the table first. That was the philosophy which led the European Union on Wednesday to publish a near-complete set of demands for United Nations climate-change talks in Copenhagen in December, in a bid to make superpowers such as China and the United States follow suit.

But ministers were not able to solve the most difficult questions on the table - leaving open the question of whether their move is anything more than a high-profile bluff.

"There is a tactical argument to say, 'Maybe we should just wait a little more to show our cards,' but there is also a very urgent need for someone to say, 'Yes, we are going to do this,' and also to indicate how exactly are we going to do it," Denmark's climate minister Connie Hedegaard told the German Press Agency dpa.

Hedegaard is set to host the Copenhagen talks.

On Wednesday, EU environment ministers approved a text setting out most of the bloc's demands for Copenhagen.

The 13-page document covers everything from emissions-reduction targets for developed and developing countries to questions of forest management and technology sharing.

Ministers took no pains to hide their glee over what is the most comprehensive climate wish-list of any multinational body to date.

"The EU will maintain its leadership role in the world" because of the agreement, EU Environment Commissioner Stavros Dimas said.

The deal "makes us the key to reaching an agreement in Copenhagen," agreed Andreas Carlgren, Sweden's environment minister, who brokered it as current holder of the EU's rotating presidency.

Some of the EU's demands, such as a call for the Copenhagen talks to set legally-binding targets for airlines and shipping companies to cut their greenhouse-gas emissions, are indeed new.

Others, such as a pledge to cut emissions to 80-95 per cent below 1990 levels by 2050, are new for the EU, but echo recommendations by UN climate-change experts.

Still others formalize long-held calls, such as the demand for developed states to join an EU emissions-trading scheme by 2015, and for rising powers to join it by 2020.

Officials said that the EU's policies in those areas have already had an impact on the world's superpowers.

"When the Americans discuss their agreement on Copenhagen or (emissions trading), one big argument is that if they don't do it fast enough, the EU will continue to have the advantage because we had the prudence to move in this direction," Dimas said.

But negotiators for the Copenhagen talks say that the EU has still not managed to play the biggest trump in its hand - and that it will not be able to call other powers' bluffs until it has done so.

That trump, quite simply, is money. Negotiators are adamant that the only way the world's rich countries will get developing states to sign up to climate-change pledges is to offer them massive funding.

But on Tuesday, EU finance ministers spectacularly failed to reach an agreement on how much the bloc should pay developing states to help them fight climate change and which EU countries should foot the bill, in a bitter fight between Eastern and Western states.

EU leaders will now have to take up the question at a summit on October 29-30. EU diplomats say that the debate is likely to be long and bitter, as billions of euros ride on the result and every member state has the right to veto proposals.

But without agreement on the funding question, officials say that the EU's chances of trumping the other players in climate poker will fade to nothing.

"Without money on the table in Copenhagen, we won't be able to reach an agreement," Dimas warned on Wednesday.

That leaves the bloc with just 10 days to put its hand in order - or risk having its leadership bid exposed as an embarrassing bluff.

"What is at stake this week and next week is the question whether the EU wants to keep its position as the driving force in international climate negotiations," Hedegaard said.

Copyright DPA

Share/Save/Bookmark

Article : ANALYSIS:Bid or bluff as the EU plays climate-change poker?
Print this article
Email this article

Stay Updated
News gadget on your Google homepage
Subscribe to a news feed in Google Reader


Related News

Obama to travel to Copenhagen climate summit - Summary
Washington - US President Barack Obama will be in Copenhagen during the early stages of a major United Nations summit aimed at curtailing global climate change, the White House said Wednesday. The Obama administration also proposed cutting its domest...

UN agency approves 'groundbreaking' anti-illegal fishing treaty
Rome - The United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) has approved a treaty that aims to close fishing ports to ships involved in illegal fishing, the Rome-based UN agency said Wednesday. The treaty, known as the Agreement on Port State M...

Indonesian police arrest Greenpeace activists in Sumatra
Jakarta - Indonesian police on Wednesday arrested 14 Greenpeace activists for blocking the export facilities of a major pulp mill company in eastern Sumatra. The activists were in police custody in Pekanbaru, the capital of Riau in eastern Sumatra, f...

New Zealand parliament passes new climate change law
Wellington - The New Zealand parliament passed a controversial new climate change law through parliament by a narrow majority on Wednesday, defying its own chief adviser on the environment. The centre-right government fast-tracked legislation setting...

Hong Kong people dump billions fewer plastic bags
Hong Kong - Four billion fewer plastic bags a year are being thrown out with the rubbish by Hong Kong people as the city's environmental consciousness grows, officials said Wednesday. A government study found there had been a 66.5-per-cent drop in th...

EXTRA: US, India agree on partnership for 'green' economy
Washington - US President Barack Obama and Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh Tuesday pledged their countries will work closely to develop clean forms of energy to help curtail the threat posed by global warming. Obama said a clean energy initiati...

2010 World Cup to have elephantine carbon footprint
Johannesburg - The 2010 football World Cup in South Africa will have an elephantine carbon footprint compared to the 2006 Cup in Germany, the South African government said Tuesday. Environmental Affairs Minister Buyelwa Sonjica told parliament that a...

Have your Say
Name
Email
Subject
Your Comment

Enter Verification code
 
  

 

 

More Environment News click here
Follow The Earth Times
Subscribe to RSS Follow Earth Times on TwitterNews by email
Share/Save/Bookmark

 
 



 
Subscribe to free Earthtimes
News Alerts by Email Click here
For RSS Feeds Click here
or Create your own RSS

Add to Google Toolbar
Breaking News
Press Releases

 

Is it possible to have 2 losers?


The Earth Times
News Category

© 2009 www.earthtimes.org, The Earth Times, All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy
Earth Times accept no responsibility or liability either directly or indirectly for views or opinions expressed in articles or comments.