Africa | America | Asia | Australasia | Europe | India | Middle East | UK | US

Supreme court: Bush officials not liable in Muslim arrests - Summary

Washington - The US Supreme Court ruled Monday that top justice officials in the administration of former president George W Bush could not be held liable for alleged discrimination in the arrest of a Pakistani man after the 2001 terrorist attacks. I...
Posted : Mon, 18 May 2009 22:11:36 GMT
By : DPA
Category : US (World)
News Alerts by Email ( click here )
US World News | Home
Washington - The US Supreme Court ruled Monday that top justice officials in the administration of former president George W Bush could not be held liable for alleged discrimination in the arrest of a Pakistani man after the 2001 terrorist attacks. In a 5-4 decision, the court ruled that former attorney general John Ashcroft and FBI Director Robert Mueller, who has held on to his job in the Obama administration, could not be sued for mistreatment that occurred when they allegedly singled out Muslim men using race and religion as their guidelines, the Los Angeles Times reported online.

Justice Anthony M Kennedy wrote the majority decision, arguing that it was not surprising that a "legitimate policy" of law enforcement aimed at finding suspects linked to the attacks "would produce a disparate, incidental impact on Arab Muslims."

"The (September 11, 2001) attacks were perpetrated by 19 Arab Muslim hijackers who counted themselves members in good standing of al-Qaeda, an Islamic fundamentalist group," Kennedy wrote.

The case was brought by a Pakistani Muslim man, Javaid Iqbal of Brooklyn, New York, who was among more than 1,200 people detained, interrogated and often denied access to lawyers in the weeks and months after the September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks.

In Iqbal's case, as with many others, charges were never filed. He claims to have been held for months in solitary confinement and to have been stripped, kicked and punched. He was in the US illegally and was later deported to Pakistan.

Monday's decision, which reversed findings by two lower courts, applied only to Iqbal's case. But typical of Supreme Court decisions, it is likely to apply broadly to similar lawsuits.

The decision left open Iqbal's right to sue jail officials who were directly responsible for his alleged abuse.

Justice David Souter, who dissented in the decision, said that Iqbal should have been allowed to try to prove his claim that "Ashcroft and Mueller were at the very least aware of the discriminatory detention policy and condoned it and perhaps even took part in devising it."

The unfair detention cases are separate from the political debate about whether the new administration under US President Barack Obama should prosecute former Bush officials who drafted policies allowing harsh interrogation tactics against overseas prisoners in the war on terrorism.

Obama has not ruled out the possibility of prosecution, saying the decision will be left to Attorney General Eric Holder, who heads the Justice Department.

Days after taking office in January, Obama banned the harsh techniques such as

Copyright DPA

Share/Save/Bookmark

Article : Supreme court: Bush officials not liable in Muslim arrests - Summary
Print this article
Email this article

Stay Updated
News gadget on your Google homepage
Subscribe to a news feed in Google Reader


Related News

Senior US senator demands 'terrorism' probe into army killings
Washington - Senior US senator Joe Lieberman has called for a congressional investigation to establish whether the mass shooting at the US Army's Fort Hood in Texas were motivated by terrorism. There had been strong warning signs that the alleged g...

Fort Hood offers prayers for victims of mass shooting
Fort Hood, Texas - Chaplains were tending to the spiritual needs of a flock shocked by a mass shooting at the US Army's Fort Hood, preparing to offer words of comfort at Sunday services. Meanwhile, inves...

'We're family' - Texas town rallies after tragedy - Feature
Killeen, Texas - Thirteen white crosses stand on the lawn of a church in Killeen, Texas, just outside the gates of Fort Hood, where days earlier a lone gunman opened fire on soldiers preparing to deploy overseas. Thirty f...

Amid mourning, authorities seek clues in Fort Hood rampage - Update
Fort Hood, Texas - As investigators tried to determine the motive behind the shooting rampage at Fort Hood, the largest US military installation in the world, the community continued to struggle Saturday with what had happened. Bl...

EXTRA: Obama: Attack on military base
Washington- The gunning-down of fellow soldiers allegedly by an army psychiatrist at the Fort Hood, Texas, military base was both heartbreaking and despicable, US President Barack Obama said during his weekly address Saturday. It is an act of violen...

Lawmakers set for major vote on US health reform
Washington - The US House of Representatives could vote Saturday evening on a landmark health reform bill that is aimed at cutting costs and extending coverage to Americans who lack insurance. The House vote would mark the biggest victory yet for Pre...

UN council calls on Afghan government to fight graft, unite country
New York - The UN Security Council called on Afghan President Hamid Karzai's government to fight corruption and the drug trade while also improving security and promoting national unity in the wake of an election marred by fraud. The council also sai...

Have your Say
Name
Email
Subject
Your Comment

Enter Verification code
 
  

 

 

More US (World) News click here
Follow The Earth Times
Subscribe to RSS Follow Earth Times on TwitterNews by email
Share/Save/Bookmark

 
 



 
Subscribe to free Earthtimes
News Alerts by Email Click here
For RSS Feeds Click here
or Create your own RSS

Add to Google Toolbar
Breaking News
Press Releases

 


The Earth Times
News Category

© 2009 www.earthtimes.org, The Earth Times, All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy
Earth Times accept no responsibility or liability either directly or indirectly for views or opinions expressed in articles or comments.