Africa | America | Asia | Australasia | Europe | India | Middle East | UK | US

Oxford students disrupt David Irving debate - Summary

Posted : Mon, 26 Nov 2007 22:26:04 GMT
By : DPA
Category : UK (World)
News Alerts by Email ( click here )
UK World News | Home
London - Angry student demonstrators forced their way Monday into an Oxford Union debating hall, disrupting an event at which the controversial historian David Irving was due to speak. Irving, who is British, has repeatedly denied the Holocaust and served a prison term in Austria for the offence.

Police said that a group of about 30 students were staging a sit- in inside the debating hall of the renowned Oxford Union, which is attached to Oxford University.

A hard core of some 30 protestors, singing and chanting anti- fascist slogans, stopped the debate from getting under way, reports said.

They had broken away from up to 500 protestors and scaled a wall to force their way into the building, shouting "shame on you" and "fascists out."

Irving and Nick Griffin, leader of Britain's racist British National Party (BNP), had arrived hours before the evening event to be escorted into the building.

They were due to take part in a debate on free speech.

Martin McCluskey from the Oxford University Students' Union said that giving Irving and Griffin a platform would be to give them "legitimacy and credibility."

"It is as if we are saying, we agree with what they are saying," he said.

But Anne Atkins, a British writer and broadcaster who was participating in the event, said it was wrong to silence those espousing controversial views.

While she was not agreeing with the two men's views, it was "dangerous and disturbing" to believe that the "majority is always right."

Despite opposition from the Oxford Student Union and the university's Muslim and Jewish societies, Oxford Union members voted by a margin of 2 to 1 to let the ticket-only event, entitled Free Speech Forum, go ahead.

The Union is well-known for hosting high-profile foreign speakers, including Henry Kissinger, Mother Teresa, Benazir Bhutto and the Dalai Lama.

In Britain, a string of politicians including Defence Secretary Des Browne and Labour politician Chris Bryant pulled out of the event after learning that they would have to share a platform with Irving and Griffin.

Julian Lewis, a Conservative member of parliament, resigned from the Union in protest.

Luke Tryl, president of the Oxford Union, said: "The men were not being given a platform to extol their views but were coming to talk about the limits of free speech."

Denis McShane, former Europe minister in the British Foreign Office, last week pulled out of an Oxford Union event after objecting to plans for "two notorious anti-Semites to be given a platform."

"To put four-star Jew-haters onto a prestigious platform like the Oxford Union is to validate modern anti-Semitism," said McShane.

Irving was sentenced in Austria in February 2006 to three years in prison for Holocaust denial but was released early in December of the same year.

Griffin has been convicted of incitement to racial hatred and denying the Holocaust.

"There is no place for racists and fascists at universities," said Yair Sivan of the Union of Jewish Students at Oxford.

Hafia Hassan, a 19-year-old French and Spanish student, who had come to listen to the debate, said: "I think we are intelligent enough to oppose these people."

Copyright DPA

Share/Save/Bookmark

Article : Oxford students disrupt David Irving debate - Summary
Print this article
Email this article

Stay Updated
News gadget on your Google homepage
Subscribe to a news feed in Google Reader


Related News

Major British paper turns against Afghan conflict, urges pullout
London - The liberal Independent on Sunday newspaper in its lead article Sunday cited waning public support for Britain's involvement in the conflict in Afghanistan and argued for a pullout. In an article titled Afghanistan: Time to Leave the newsp...

Two punters crack 100-million-euro lottery jackpot in Britain
London - Two players in Britain have cracked the jackpot of 100 million euros (146 million dollars) in the Euromillions lottery, the Camelot lottery company said Saturday. The two winning tickets would divide the pot evenly. In the event that the tic...

Brown warns Afghanistan over loss of international support - Summary
London- Britain Friday warned Afghan President Hamid Karzai that he risked the withdrawal of international support if his government fails to improve security and root out corruption. I am not prepared to put the lives of British men and women in ha...

British ministers concede fading hopes on firm climate change deal
London - The British government echoed US warnings Friday that a binding deal on climate change is now unlikely to be agreed upon at a United Nations (UN) climate change summit in Copenhagen next month. The barriers to agreement on climate finance r...

Brown warns Afghanistan over international support
London - Afghan President Hamid Karzai risks the withdrawal of international support if his government should fail to improve security and root out corruption, Prime Minister Gordon Brown warned Friday. I am not prepared to put the lives of British ...

British soldier dies in Afghanistan as war fatigue grows
London - Britain Thursday reported the death of another soldier in southern Afghanistan, taking to 230 the total number of military fatalities since the conflict began eight years ago. The Ministry of Defence (MoD) said a soldier had died in a roadsi...

PROFILE: David Miliband - Labour's rising star - tipped for EU job
London - Relative youth, a formidable brain, a winning smile and a recently-discovered Russian relative are among the characteristics that distinguish David Miliband from most other politicians. Nick-named brains, the 44-year-old wonderboy of New L...

Have your Say
Name
Email
Subject
Your Comment

Enter Verification code
 
  

 

 
Your Comments

'I believe in free speech, but...'
By: Robert , Mon, 26 Nov 2007 22:31:59 GMT

Saying you ‘believe in free speech, but...’ is meaningless, just as saying ‘I’m not racist, but...’. Either we are free to say and think what we believe or we are not. Liberals should be inside the room arguing with them and proving them wrong, not just protesting pointlessly outside or childishly sitting at the debating table and disrupting the debate. You can’t win the arguments if you don’t fight the battles. Banning things just makes you look like they are scared to take them on.



More UK (World) News click here
Follow The Earth Times
Subscribe to RSS Follow Earth Times on TwitterNews by email
Share/Save/Bookmark

 
 



 
Subscribe to free Earthtimes
News Alerts by Email Click here
For RSS Feeds Click here
or Create your own RSS

Add to Google Toolbar
Breaking News
Press Releases

 


The Earth Times
News Category

© 2009 www.earthtimes.org, The Earth Times, All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy
Earth Times accept no responsibility or liability either directly or indirectly for views or opinions expressed in articles or comments.